Explosion de Beyrouth : le désastre reconstitué

17 nov. 2020
385 970 Weergaven

[Activez les sous-titres pour la version française]
Peu après 18 heures le 4 août, une explosion a dévasté le port de Beyrouth, tuant plus de 200 personnes et en blessant plus de 6 500 autres. Forensic Architecture a été invité par le journal en ligne égyptien Mada Masr à examiner les informations disponibles en source ouverte, y compris des vidéos, des photographies et des documents, permettant de fournir une chronologie et une modélisation 3D précises des événements.
☞ La maquette, les vidéos géolocalisées et le matériel source utilisé dans les recherches : github.com/forensic-architecture/models/tree/master/65
☞ Les enquêtes de Forensic Architecture : www.mediapart.fr/journal/international/dossier/les-enquetes-de-forensic-architecture
☞ Abonnez-vous à Mediapart : www.mediapart.fr/abonnement#at_medium=custom7&at_campaign=1050
☞ Abonnez-vous à la chaîne NLworld de Mediapart : nlworld.info

Reacties
  • Wow, le travail fourni est énorme ! La modélisation est parfaite!

    KZY prod.KZY prod.2 uur geleden
  • Superbe travail d'analyse, comprendre est essentiel

    David AckermansDavid Ackermans3 uur geleden
  • That's too painful to watch. Thanks for the explanation but we are still saddned by this Ps: I'm not lebanese but I'm still sad by this and I feel for the amazing lebanese people

    Sara kSara k7 uur geleden
  • WOW INCREDIBLE TODAY'S 3D RENDERING TECHNOLOGY

    C1C110 uur geleden
  • Material storage rules? Who needs those? (Not 3rd world countries, that's who)

    Ask to seduce MissAsk to seduce Miss13 uur geleden
  • Regardez ce que donne une bombe thermobarique est dite moi si vous y voyez des similitudes.... Moi j'en vois . nlworld.info/key/video/pYeblMy3i6mEhJ4

    Ano NymousAno Nymous13 uur geleden
  • Such a well-done video!

    maria ghazirimaria ghaziri14 uur geleden
  • Wow wow! This is so impressive. I can appreciate the effort and painstaking attention to detail. If there is a follow up it would be super interesting to indicate the location of the door the welders were repairing that supposedly was the source of ignition. And also overlay of the bomb crater over your detonation sphere and compare how their centre origins compare. The bomb crater centre point looks like it correlates well with your placement of the explosion sphere slightly south of the mid point of the warehouse. Thanks for the video 👍🏻

    Mike BellMike Bell16 uur geleden
    • the port, as the bill of laden did not match the content of the boat. It was strictly on the papers that it was stated as nitrates when in fact it was explosive materials.

      Ask to seduce MissAsk to seduce Miss13 uur geleden
  • Good job

    Slx SlxSlx Slx16 uur geleden
  • I can´t wait to see 9/11 thus treated. Let´s prove the inconsistences!!!

    alistairosealistairose21 uur geleden
  • What happened to those poor dudes filming closely ? ...

    Lyp3Lyp323 uur geleden
    • They probably still looking for them

      Keven PokinKeven Pokin9 uur geleden
  • Great job. How many people worked on this model and video?

    technics6technics623 uur geleden
  • But when an UFO is around there is no Camera around and if one is actually there, it takes only blurry Pictures.

    Azuris190Azuris190Dag geleden
    • wtf are you even talking about

      Maël CMaël C4 uur geleden
  • The color changes to a darker shade... Et ils ont besoin d'un expert en explosif pour dire que ça suggère qu'un autre matériel est en feu...

    TheCentauryTheCentauryDag geleden
  • Amazing job bro 👍💪🎊

    Ghailane Garcia Abdel KarimGhailane Garcia Abdel KarimDag geleden
  • Mediapart... quel professionnalisme! wow! solidarité avec le peuple Libanais

    Damien BouilliezDamien BouilliezDag geleden
    • La vidéo est tout simplement libre d'accès est de droit pour tout le monde, Mediapart n'y est pour rien, il a simplement repris la vidéo d'un tiers

      Robin KHRobin KH5 uur geleden
  • Très belle présentation 👏👏. Sinon il y aura pas de responsable désigné car la corruption gangrène tous les services de l’Etat , en Hold up par les anciens princes et criminels de la guerre Libanaise, qui sont toujours au pouvoir depuis 30 ans...

    Abdallah GHALAYINIAbdallah GHALAYINIDag geleden
  • On prévient , on mes en garde , et quand on écoute pas il y des accidents de la sorte

    Aleksii!Aleksii!Dag geleden
  • This is impressive analytical science. The world has changed.

    Anthony MiyazakiAnthony MiyazakiDag geleden
  • Travail très convaincant. 👏 Chapeau bas !.

    Chris BreizhooChris BreizhooDag geleden
  • Why do you need an invitation to do something with open source material

    Norm MacdonaldNorm MacdonaldDag geleden
    • Troll

      Fyask0Fyask08 uur geleden
  • That guy filming just metres away from that building must surely be dead or he is extremely extremely lucky that he left the area 4:45

    Biker ChapmanBiker ChapmanDag geleden
    • If the video is retrievable that means to camera it was recorded on was undamaged meaning the dude carrying it was likely undamage as well.

      DinmaSalitzeyDinmaSalitzey16 uur geleden
    • can someone tag me if anyone knows thx u.

      dayikdayik23 uur geleden
  • What about reports that mentioned that it wasn't ammonium nitrate that were in the warehouse, it was in fact explosive materials, and it was the reason the boat was seased at the port, as the bill of laden did not match the content of the boat. It was strictly on the papers that it was stated as nitrates when in fact it was explosive materials.

    Georges HaddadGeorges HaddadDag geleden
    • Also commenting on the video, excellent work in combining all videos but please consider alternate explosive materials.

      Georges HaddadGeorges HaddadDag geleden
  • Si on aurait voulu faire exploser une bombe et faire passer ça pour un accident, on aurait pas fait mieux

    P.I.O 07P.I.O 07Dag geleden
  • This is very PRO! Nice work!

    smietniksmietnikDag geleden
  • Can we get a video like this about 9/11???

    Bjorn Van Der LindenBjorn Van Der LindenDag geleden
  • And the twin tower ?!

    Trunks CorpTrunks CorpDag geleden
  • well done!

    Cássio CamposCássio CamposDag geleden
  • Capitalism, isn't it great? "We can save(make) a money if we just throw all this shit in the building, let's get it done boys, I wanna get home early today!" They should find out all those involved in allowing this to happy, from the low guys who did the job to the highest politicians who hired the foremen, accountants, regulators, managers, etc... probably around 200 people or so... then publicly hang them all but the more important their position the more slowly they are hung. Remember, this went on for 6 years. Thousands of people new about this and ignored the problem.

    Jo BlowJo BlowDag geleden
    • Yep let's kill more people, that's gonna solve all the problems :)

      logitech4873logitech4873Dag geleden
  • pourquoi ne pas parler du missile que l on vois sur une des vidéo

    dominique Martin d'Escriennedominique Martin d'EscrienneDag geleden
    • @Nayllko tu veut que l on en parle!!

      dominique Martin d'Escriennedominique Martin d'Escrienne39 minuten geleden
    • @dominique Martin d'Escrienne Ah oui, quand même. Non merci, laisse ce pauvre vieux tranquille, je me débrouille très bien sans lui 🙂

      NayllkoNayllko8 uur geleden
    • Invoc son nom change de mentalité pour être sauvé si tu le fais d un coeur sincères et contrie !!!

      dominique Martin d'Escriennedominique Martin d'Escrienne10 uur geleden
    • Il veut te délivrer de té angoisse cochemar et addiction

      dominique Martin d'Escriennedominique Martin d'Escrienne10 uur geleden
    • Parle a Dieu dit lui ta soutenance ta névrose ta frustration il veut te donner la paix l amour la joie

      dominique Martin d'Escriennedominique Martin d'Escrienne10 uur geleden
  • Fantastic job !!

    Thomas ThomasThomas ThomasDag geleden
  • That was the perfect recipe for disaster. Lots of hot fuel, open ammonium nitrate in very poor storage and a lot of heat. It could have been very easily avoided.

    Joel AJoel ADag geleden
  • Thank you for this very clear and detailed analysis.

    Gaurav DharGaurav DharDag geleden
  • Faut l'indiquer que la vidéo est en anglais avec un titre français....

    wenceslas peyrounetwenceslas peyrounetDag geleden
    • Les sous titres sont en français.

      Julien GullaceJulien GullaceDag geleden
  • Its sad to think that everyone who took the close up videos are most likely past away :(

    Justin DJustin DDag geleden
  • See this video specially point 14, nlworld.info/key/video/t5F5e6qmsK6QmqI

    From Here & ThereFrom Here & ThereDag geleden
  • RIP for all those who took the closest shots

    龍神拳Ryuujinken龍神拳RyuujinkenDag geleden
  • Un scénario terriblement plausible serait qu'il y aurait eut de la corruption pour rendre tout cela possible, et un complot depuis même l'abandon du navire à l'origine de la cargaison. Quand on connait les pratiques du mot sade (et sadique justement) et que l'ont sait que le S bola aurait été établi dans ces quartier, et bien l'ont peut conclure que 2+2=/=5...

    Pascal BrietiPascal BrietiDag geleden
  • I heard initially that rules/guidelines for storing these dangerous materials were overlooked, but my God, I had no idea the level of negligence at play here. The way the bags were stored, allowed to deteriorate, and were in close proximity to each other and to other materials strikes a hard conclusion that whoever was in charge of this warehouse was grossly incompetent and unfit. Those who knew about the danger, were in a position of power to act, and failed to do so are also liable for the lives lost and damage incurred that day. A tragedy of criminal incompetence.

    GoTeamScotchGoTeamScotchDag geleden
  • August seems like it was so long ago with all we have gone through since then.

    StellerwolfStellerwolfDag geleden
  • Material storage rules? Who needs those? (Not 3rd world countries, that's who)

    Jahn KaplankJahn KaplankDag geleden
    • Troll

      Fyask0Fyask08 uur geleden
  • "We consulted a UN Explosive expert to tell us that when the smoke changed to a darker tone its a indication the fuel source has changed......" just wow lol! Had to stop watching after that.

    Offensive BiasOffensive BiasDag geleden
    • ​@logitech4873 Because he never studied chemistry. He doesn't have the prerequisites to understand a scientific explanation, so he might as well stop looking. Wise decision.

      NayllkoNayllkoDag geleden
    • Why?

      logitech4873logitech4873Dag geleden
  • excellent video. And i hope that it's helpful to many people.

    Kelly HoferKelly Hofer2 dagen geleden
  • C est un attentat terroriste

    Hamid SelesHamid Seles2 dagen geleden
    • Parfaitement. Avec une technologie alieno-reptilienne.

      NayllkoNayllkoDag geleden
  • What the hell? Let's put explosives next to the flammables next to the explosives in a haphazard way...

    Zorn27Zorn272 dagen geleden
  • Le truc qui m'a fait halluciner c'est le moment où l'on apprend qu'il y avait aussi du thé et du café ... des denrées alimentaires !!

    cLx JaggycLx Jaggy2 dagen geleden
  • wtf thank you

    ahab_dotaahab_dota2 dagen geleden
  • Ça semble être du super travail de reconstitution ! 👍

    barborerbarborer2 dagen geleden
  • To be recommended !

    Jerome EmeriauJerome Emeriau2 dagen geleden
  • Bravo!

    Robert LucasRobert Lucas2 dagen geleden
  • Thank you very much for posting this information.

    dhiemart32dhiemart322 dagen geleden
  • Would be GREAT if a similar analysis was done of videos from 911... oh yes... most were confiscated by the US government, especially the ones from the areas surrounding the Pentagon

    RMCRMC2 dagen geleden
  • Good work here, a most interesting video.

    Malcolm AnonMalcolm Anon2 dagen geleden
  • It's clear a ton of work was put into this. Great analysis man

    GangaGremlinGangaGremlin2 dagen geleden
  • Thank you. Wishing peace to all the victims of this tragedy.

    dashdotdashdot2 dagen geleden
  • I guess 85 ignorant idiots whose decisions made this happen did not like the video

    Stellar73bStellar73b2 dagen geleden
  • Wow, amazing video, great work.

    Skinny-Fat ManSkinny-Fat Man2 dagen geleden
  • I'm flabbergasted by the quality of this video, thank you for such a professional examination, bravo!

    BodhiBodhi2 dagen geleden
  • The people doing those close up videos didn't survive did they? Edit: the firefighters in the video are all missing presumed dead: www.firehouse.com/safety-health/video/21149329/photo-video-capture-beirut-firefighters-moments-before-blast www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/08/06/beirut-explosion-missing-firefighters-hailed-heroes/

    than217than2172 dagen geleden
    • Exactly what I was thinking. Sad..

      Nie CxNie Cx2 dagen geleden
  • Great video. You should make one about the explosion in Mari, Cyprus!

    AndreasAndreas2 dagen geleden
  • Cette enquete est meilleurs que tout ce que les enquetteurs libannais commissionné par un gouvernement corrompus pourront faire une enquette bien menée s interessant aux faits ne glissant pas dans la theorie du conplot contrairement a ce que beaucoup veulent nous faire croire ils se cachent derriere ces theories pour masquer leur negligence et leur corruption pour vous dire le president libannais a demande de la france des images sateillite pour voir si il n y avait pas des avions d israel dans la region juste pathetique .

    LB kLB k2 dagen geleden
  • ne soyez pas inquiet tous ceci va bientôt stopper et toutes les personnes qui auront participés aux genocides de l’humanité dans le monde sera bien remercier mits hors de fonction 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    m hm h2 dagen geleden
  • Incredibly detailed and informative video!

    xGeoThumbsxGeoThumbs2 dagen geleden
  • Fascinating and amazing work. This is exactly what I wanted to see back when the explosion happened to get a clear picture. I hope that the people responsible are punished, I hate it when they are specifically warned multiple times and still don't do anything. Would they really prefer to deal with this fallout rather than just prevent it... Very negligent.

    scalpingsnakescalpingsnake2 dagen geleden
  • Brilliant work by all those involved and bravo for providing it free and publicly available 👍🏽👍🏽

    kaiZen weisZkaiZen weisZ2 dagen geleden
  • Кстати Крым уже с ЯО, там где ЯО, там территорию уже никто не отберёт. Ни США, ни ЕС. Украина лохи, что отдали свои 5000 или более ракет РФ ещё после развала. Потому-то Украину и деребанят. В Белоруссии тоже нет ЯО и её пытаются деребанить. Грузию уже раздеребанили, они жили до 2008 года лучше, чем сейчас живут. Та Европа кроме реформ ужасных им толком ничего не дала. ЗП низкие. Туризм упал, россиян мало к ним едздит. А До 2008 года главным доходом экономики Грузии были туристы из РФ и продажи вина. Сейчас в Грузии винодельни закрывают из-за конкуренции с ЕС. Их специально, как в Украине с животноводством беда, так в Грузии беда с виноградниками. Вот такая она ЕС. Англия от туда сбежала и рада. Польша хочет сбежать, но увы её не отпустят, так просто. Болгария Греция тоже хотят выйти. В Последнее время народ Франции бунтует. Народ Испании, Португалии. Никто больше не хочет в ЕС быть. Только некоторые страны. У которых экономик нет своих и люди заробитчане почти все. Вот те страны в ЕС хотят быть. КАК в Украине. За безвиз готовы убить. Потому что без него Западенцам грозит нищета. Вот такие дела. А Когда-то было СССР и все мы были одной дружной мощной страной. Которая во всё практически была первой. А теперь последней. Все мозги работают на ЕС и США. Фактически все фрилансеры это враги народа. Потому как поднимают экономику других стран. Да НДС они платят. Только то НДС до одного места. Когда лишь на нём страна держится, а не на собственных успехах и производствах. Это всё позор. Говорить, какие заробитчане молодцы, бабки в страну привозят. Не молодцы они. Потому что страна лишь за счёт налогов и живёт. А не собственных достижений. Короче. В 2021 будет хана всем, кроме Азиатов. Азиаты даже РФ предали. Потому, как Азиаты хуже жидов. Жиды за чистоту расы своей и Азиаты тоже. Расисты всегда этот мир приводили к войне и уничтожению

    Andrey DneprAndrey Dnepr2 dagen geleden
  • А где видео начала пожара. Чё скрываем? А то момент только, как уже дымится на всех видео в ютюбе, а момента, когда дыма нет и потом он появляется нигде нет. Я думаю Через Ливан в Иран шло из РФ ЯО или что-то типо того. Иран уже обогатил свой Уран, а вот куда его так сказать, как начинку начинять не сделал. А РФ им прислало ЯО, без начинки. Вот и всё. США это узнали и склад беспилотником подожгли, ракетой, той что случайно сняли на видео зеваки до начала пожара, которая летит под углом 45 градусов и попадает в склад. Инцидент замяли. РФ США сказало, ещё раз такое повторится и будет как с Кубой полная закрытость РФ, от мира, как для экспорта, так и для импорта любых товаров. Вот и всё. Зачем Ирану ЯО. Ну как зачем. Чтобы не было того, что в Белоруссии происходит и в Украине произошло и Грузии, не было захвата власти страны Европой и США. Чтобы не стать колонией США и ЕС и АНГЛИИ. Вот и всё. Но увы не повезло Ирану. Пока доставить к ним устройство не удаётся. Через инет схемы передать или через посла чертежи не вариант. Если будет утечка, то все поймут, кто дал Ирану чертежи ЯО. Вот и всё. А то что было на складе, к стране какой либо владеющей ЯО привязать нереально. Ну вот как можно ракету, без опознавательных знаков и схем к какой-либо стране привязать. Никак. Думаю РФ всё равно передаст как-то Ирану ракету либо чертежи. И если этот факт докажут. РФ и Ирану жопа. Нефть резко упадёт. И РФ хана, и Ирану тоже.

    Andrey DneprAndrey Dnepr2 dagen geleden
  • An amazing compilation of data to help reconstruct the progression of the disaster in Beirut harbor. What a horrific tragedy. Decades of armed conflict, corruption and hatred have left ruins. I pray for the people of Lebanon and for a re-birth of a once wonderful city.

    Mike BaginyMike Baginy2 dagen geleden
  • The people behind this investigation is absolutely brilliant. I never knew you could withdraw so much information from short videos to such accuracy. I'm completely blown away by the intelligence these people and software must have to do something like this.

    Philip JonssonPhilip Jonsson2 dagen geleden
    • Well, liveleak, reddit and youtube users were all doing the same thing during the days that followed. New videos where placed cronologicaly with the ones already found, and if they covered the same timeframe they were often synched and running in paralell. But yeah, I agree that this is better and more professional, especially the mapping of everything.

      Johan LarssonJohan Larsson2 dagen geleden
  • Super. Très pertinent . Bravo

    atomic jocatomic joc2 dagen geleden
  • Excelent work. I rushed that day and made a video guessing it was Stuxnet. Had to delete it now.

    Octarine CodeOctarine Code2 dagen geleden
  • Excellent travail ! quel travail de recherche et modélisation ; j'ai mal suivi : a t on la trace effective des 2500 T d'engrais ? pour le reste cela semble bien tracé

    alain batoralain bator2 dagen geleden
    • Oui, tout un tas de documents l'atteste, d'ailleurs ça s'est su tout de suite.

      NayllkoNayllko2 dagen geleden
  • First of all, great analysis. I have never seen something this professional and the plume color analysis really opened my eyes. However so much questions are coming up to me What is the main cause people died in de blast radius? Flying parts, air pressure, toxic gasses, collapsing buildings, fire? How were these causes capable of killing and injuring so many people while the warehouse was not that closely located to residential areas and even located at sea side. I don’t know the population density of the residential area of course but when I visualize it, it is still too many to me Why didn’t men take earlier notice since it was known that the content of the warehouse was highly explosive and the risk of lots of people’s lives may be involved?

    Hassan CohmdanHassan Cohmdan3 dagen geleden
    • Most likely were the radius around the explosions. The blast pressure and shockwave alone can destroy your internal organs. Second is the shrapnel that throws in the air. Think of all that debris or little stones traveling at 200kph hitting you. Further out you have the shockwave dropping shards of glass from broken windows to the people below. So many factors, its a miracle more were not killed.

      ZeusKaboozeZeusKaboozeDag geleden
  • Amazing work of analysis

    tartineboy41tartineboy413 dagen geleden
  • *To mislead the masses, use of modern technology can change the views and mindset of those of myopic intellect. Those behind this dastardly atrocious act are the very barbaric people illegally occupying and perpetuating misery not only in the Middle East but the world over, yet no one has the courage or intelligence to challenge the proposed theory set forth in this video, undoubtedly purporting to the idea that fireworks and ammonium nitrate was the cause of this explosion. IN THE LAND OF THE BLIND, THE ONE EYED MAN IS KING*

    SSRSSR3 dagen geleden
    • To do that you need 1/ proof that the leading theory is wrong 2/ an alternative theory 3/ Convincing proof that the alternative theory explain the observations better and isn't doing any cherry-picking or other typical misrepresentation of the facts that we see in many "alternative" theories.

      thear1sthear1s3 dagen geleden
  • Great work ...and hold on our brothers

    Black EyesBlack Eyes3 dagen geleden
  • Excellent travail d'information de mediapart l'un des seuls véritables médias citoyens patriote qui respectent la charte de Munich et informe réellement la population en france un média totalement indépendant propre honnête partial neutre du vrai travail de pro de journaliste professionnel

    michel kaddourmichel kaddour3 dagen geleden
  • Great AAR job !

    Sam CrosswordsSam Crosswords3 dagen geleden
  • The video is great and the details are incredible. We can see how much work was put into this investigation. Unfortunately, as a Lebanese citizen I can assure you that no one will be held responsible for this negligence. Shame...

    Nadim J. NEHMENadim J. NEHME3 dagen geleden
  • Pas d'enquête sur le covid pour Plenel...?

    Nico NicoNico Nico3 dagen geleden
  • so everyone in the country knew cause of media attention and court that there is highly explosive material and a short time after it went viral through media the warehouse bursts... even if it was a worker that done some repairs that are such unlikly events again. 5 years it was sitting there and only after people knew which dangerous stuff is in there it explodes/ a fire started in that warehouse

    Koronas89Koronas893 dagen geleden
  • You can see how much work has been put in making such a detailed 3D representation of the events and also the video. Amazing content!

    Povilas NorvaišasPovilas Norvaišas3 dagen geleden
  • Could n’t we have the same kind of work for Notre Dame de Paris ?

    nicolas artheaunicolas artheau3 dagen geleden
    • How many people died in the Notre Dame de Paris fire?

      J FJ F3 dagen geleden
  • Great great work!!! Thank you very much for sharing it

    mrblonde8888mrblonde88883 dagen geleden
  • comme des sacs d'engrais mais en plus cher, et il a de jouer avec le feu juste a coté

    Monsieur GodzyllaMonsieur Godzylla3 dagen geleden
  • IT ‘S A ORANGE MISSILE THE MOHAB BOMB Stop your lies

    M# ]13[M# ]13[3 dagen geleden
    • @logitech4873 Everybody knows that a missile explosion starts by making a little smoke for a few minutes before exploding. It is a proof.

      NayllkoNayllkoDag geleden
    • No it wasn't. It was a well-known storage location of large amounts of ammonium nitrate, which is explosive.

      logitech4873logitech48733 dagen geleden
  • This whole process of reconstructing the events is pretty amazing to watch. Very nice job.

    ConsequatorConsequator3 dagen geleden
    • Now do 9/11 plz

      Louis GreubelLouis GreubelDag geleden
  • Énorme !! merci pour cette vidéo extrêmement intéressante, cela serait bien d'avoir la même chose sur le 11/09/2001

    Jeremy DuhamelJeremy Duhamel3 dagen geleden
    • totalement faux !!! 1)la date est 21/09/2001. 2) 360T d'engrais dans une usine ou l'on fabrique de l'engrais n'a rien d'anormale ... l'engrais à AZF était en bonne état ... la substance qui a pollué le tas d'engrais est soit disant du chlore ...pour provoquer une réaction entre ammonitrate et le chlore... il faut le même tonnage de l'un et l'autre des éléments. par contre l'usine à coté SNPE société national des poudres et explosif juste à coté avait des citernes à comburants servant aux fusées Ariane comme combustible juste à coté ... les 2 subtance servant à la propulsion des fusée sont produit a 2 endroits différent pour la sécurité (une notification avait souligné une fuite sur une des citernes qui à été presque vidée ) cette substance est très corrosive ... tellement quelle a endommagée un transformateur EDF .provoquant des courts circuit ...le comburant a attaqué aussi l'ammonitrate en plus du transformateur ...elle est hautement inflammable ...la température augmentant brutalement elle provoque une explosion juste à coté du tas d'engrais se qui provoqua une seconde explosion ...celle qu'on retient. 3) pour raison d'état , on nous cache la vérité ... car à l'époque la SNPE était quasiment en faillite ... et c'était à l'état français de payer les réparations avant et après l'explosion !!! 4) la droite et la gauche sont toutes deux coupables ...Jospin 1 er ministre Chirac président de la république . car AZF est classé Seveso 2 et de même pour la SNPE . dans le premier cas il y a arrêt de l'usine tant que les normes ne sont pas respecté , c'est beaucoup plus souple dans les entreprises d'état .

      Bertrand robin taudouBertrand robin taudou8 uur geleden
  • Do this for 911. Brilliant. My condolences

    Noble LairdNoble Laird3 dagen geleden
    • There's been countless analyses of 9/11.

      logitech4873logitech48733 dagen geleden
    • They don't want to get suicided

      ralexluralexlu3 dagen geleden
  • J'espère que le peuple libanais a accès à cette vidéo... pour mettre le gouvernement face à ses responsabilités !

    Kyat SenseiKyat Sensei3 dagen geleden
    • Les autorités portuaire pas nécessairement le gouvernement. Mais un scénario terriblement plausible serait qu'il y aurait eut de la corruption pour rendre tout cela possible, et un complot depuis même l'abandon du navire à l'origine de la cargaison. Quand on connait les pratiques du mot sade (et sadique justement) et que l'ont sait que le S bola aurait été établi dans ces quartier, et bien l'ont peut conclure que 2+2=/=5...

      Pascal BrietiPascal BrietiDag geleden
  • Wow, this is amazing forensic work!

    d cd c3 dagen geleden
  • But what started the fire

    legitmontrellthigpenlegitmontrellthigpen3 dagen geleden
  • definitely a conspiracy here.

    CapJacksonCapJackson3 dagen geleden
    • Nope. Just ammonium nitrate being explosive as usual.

      logitech4873logitech48733 dagen geleden
    • Proof ? Source ? Relevant and valid argumentation ?

      Baz TBaz T3 dagen geleden
  • Thank you for publishing this. It was a very informative video. Thank you for providing the data to the public as well.

    JoshJosh3 dagen geleden
  • Where are all the conspiracy whackos claiming this was an inside job by the Illuminati, Bilderberger Group, the Lizard People, and the Clinton crew? I mean, it is clearly obvious that this really is NOT an accident, so it must have been a conspiracy... note, for instance, there are no planes nor even parts of planes. So it's clearly a hoax!

    micheal49micheal493 dagen geleden
  • Amazing work with the video, timeline and 3D modelling! I wonder which software were used for creating this?

    Mike RansbyMike Ransby3 dagen geleden
  • 4:49 I wonder if that person is still alive.

    ccrpalexccrpalex3 dagen geleden
    • He's not, he survived the initial fireworks explosion, but was vaporized like 30 seconds later. Horrible.

      Giuliano López RaffoGiuliano López Raffo2 dagen geleden
    • They could be, people were found alive in the rubble. They were shielded by the grain silo.

      deus vultdeus vult2 dagen geleden
    • obviously not :/

      Unknown EightUnknown Eight3 dagen geleden
    • Unfortunately he/she died

      Kei OikawaKei Oikawa3 dagen geleden
  • Aint no body got time for this

    DarkoDarko3 dagen geleden
  • How the Hell did only 200 people die????

    Bmak23 MalkamakiBmak23 Malkamaki3 dagen geleden
  • Great work

    BoaBoa3 dagen geleden
NLworld